Blog

  • URBim | for just and inclusive cities

    Victoria Okoye, Lagos Community Manager

    In marginalized communities like Ajegunle and Oshodi, the BornTroWay Creative Arts Project is empowering and spotlighting youth art creativity. The project started in Ajegunle, considered one of Lagos’ harshest slum settlements. But the project capitalizes on the contradictions within this space: Ajegunle, like other blighted areas, is often typecast for its challenges and labeled a slum, an informal and marginalized community. However, it is also a thriving place where some of the country’s premier athletes and performers have grown up: There’s Emmanuel Amuneke, a former footballer who represented Nigeria in the 1994 World Cup, and also Don Jazzy, the president and founder of the major music label Mo Hits Records, which produces successful music acts who have reached national and international fame. Despite its social and economic challenges, there is creativity — often untapped — in such communities.

    The organization’s name is a play on words; the Nigerian pidgin phrase born troway (“born throw away”) refers to the alienation and marginalization of these youth from mainstream society. The project’s aim is in celebrating the talent of young people in these communities, and giving them the opportunity to express their unique voice.

    “I always think words matter a lot in terms of inspiring and projecting feelings and reality,” says Ilaria Chessa, BornTroWay’s co-founder — who, along with international music artist Ade Bantu, founded the organization in 2011. In their brainstorming sessions, she says they discussed how kids from these deprived communities are treated as born troway — left there, abandoned, for life to take care of them. “Why not choose a word that actually pierces through the conscious of people and makes them see the truth behind the labels that they use?” she questioned. The youth participants may initially see themselves as marginalized, she said, but they bring a new and different definition through their artistic creations. “Rather, it’s those people in society who are looking at these kids as worthless, as if they don’t stand a chance — it is they who are missing out — by not investing in the talents that these kids have at so many levels.”

    The project’s formula is simple: a competitive public audition, through which just over a dozen youth are selected, then an intensive, five-day creativity training workshop, and then, finally, a public performance. Through the five-day youth arts training — focused on dance, drama, spoken word, and music — the project builds the talents, self-esteem, and consciousness of young people (from the ages of 15-22 years) who, as part of their training, create an original script and choreography for public performance.

    The team includes Ilaria Chessa, a former development economist and film festival organizer, as producer and co-founder; Ade Bantu, an award-winning musical artist, as co-founder, music facilitator, and creative director; culture, art, and media consultant Ropo Ewenla and drama instructor Kayode Omolola, who serve as acting and theatre facilitators; spoken word poet, writer, and teacher AJ Dagga Tolar, who facilitates the spoken word and music; and Segun Adefila, a performance artist who facilitates the dance portion of the workshop.

    From the margins to center stage

    Working through these youth, the project also aims to promote peace and unity. The project helps these young people to come out of their shell, explore, and exhibit their creative talents. Through dance, poetry, theatre, and music, their public performances regularly feature calls for community action and improvement, from addressing waste and pollution to education, from child abuse and marginalization to collective responsibility.

    It was in Ajegunle that BornTroWay was launched in May 2011. From there, the project took its initiative to Port Harcourt in October 2011 and Durban, South Africa in December 2011. While in Durban, the participants also took part in the World Climate Conference. For its fourth edition in August 2012, BornTroWay returned to Lagos in the Oshodi community. The Oshodi public performance took place in Cairo Market, where youth performed original music and theatre for a diverse audience. The lyrics for the original song the youth performed called for the residents to transform their community into a better place, free of violence, a place of peace and harmony.

    For you and I to talk together
    As a family, in peace and harmony
    We can make Oshodi a better place
    For you and you, for me and you
    We can make Oshodi a better place
    In Oshodi we don’t wan fight

    the children sing in this video of their Cairo Market performance, captured by local news coverage of the creative arts project.

    For its fifth edition, BornTroWay worked with youth in the Bariga community of Lagos. Altogether, Chessa estimates, BornTroWay has worked with nearly 200 youth in its work so far.

    Planting the seeds for new opportunities

    For the youth participants, BornTroWay is making a difference in their lives that goes far beyond teaching them to dance, to act, write a song or rap. Even in the first few days of each workshop, Chessa says, the difference she sees in many of the kids is amazing. At the beginning of the workshop, she sees kids who lack confidence, who don’t know how to present themselves. Yet from the second day, she and her team see a new set of people; even the light she sees in their eyes is amazing, she says.

    “The transformation is a marvel to observe,” she says. “Because it’s only a five-day course … it’s just there to plant a seed of inspiration, and then that seed is watered by the kids themselves. It’s just basically a wake-up call to say, ‘Hey, you guys, have you seen what you’ve got?’”

    Former participants can speak endlessly to the skills and insights they’ve gained from their experience. Some, like Godson, a 23-year old youth turned musical artist, are following a more predictable path: “As I’m talking to you now, I have a record deal, and just I launched my album last week,” he says. Godson participated in the BornTroWay Oshodi workshop in August 2012. His album, Sabulou (Hausa for “soap”) refers to his call for everyone to wash away bad problems and thoughts through dance.

    “I learned a lot, I learned to believe in myself,” affirms Godson, who says one of the major talents he gained through the workshop was in dance, as well as support in his music from Bantu. “Whatever I am doing in my career, I’m always with BornTroWay,” he says. “We’re like family, we’re a family.”

    18-year-old Franchesca from Ajegunle, who recently completed her secondary school study, says the most important lessons she gained from the workshop were on teamwork, humility, and love. “If you say you want to work on your own, you won’t achieve anything in life,” she said. “You have to carry people along, you have to work as a team.” She’s now part of a team working to organize a concert in February for BroTroWay Ajegunle, putting into practice the lessons she’s learned from her experience.

    While some of the project’s participants may continue with careers in the arts, Chessa says that the important takeaway for these kids is the self-discovery of their talents and how to use them, in whatever facet of life. “We are using arts as a means to awaken kids self-confidence and appreciation for hard work, focus, and teamwork. But at the same time, it doesn’t mean that we are hoping that everybody becomes an artist,” Chessa says. “With that self-confidence, they become a leader in any walk of life that they happen to be in … They may discover their talents in the arts, or they may become doctors or nurses; it doesn’t matter. What matters is that the spirit with which they are doing these things is a leading spirit.”

    “We want to reawaken the sense of self-worth in our youth, so that they can truly play their role in our society,” she adds.

    Future opportunities

    In a little over a year, BornTroWay has built a strong, successful history of performances in Nigeria and South Africa. In the future, BornTroWay and its leadership team look to partner with local organizations and other artists — and, eventually, to set up permanent, accessible community centers as spaces where youth can come, create, share, and network, making their ideas a reality. With all of the instructors based in Lagos, it also makes logistical sense to continue focusing on the city’s more accessible communities, and Chessa says that the team is looking to launch initiatives in Mushin, Obalende, and Makoko.

    “It is about making an impact in an environment of young people who are living at different levels of neglect, either by the government or by the general society,” said Ropo Enwenla, facilitator for theatre arts with BornTroWay, during the Ajegunle workshop.

    “If we didn’t for once think that it was going to make a difference, then we wouldn’t have come,” Ewenla has said. “We believe that we have a package, that can, in all situations, when applied correctly, bring about social change, transformation, and positive development.”

    To see BornTroWay Creative Project’s work in action, see the video of their work in Ajegunle:

    In Port Harcourt, Nigeria:

    In Durban, South Africa:

  • URBim | for just and inclusive cities

    Event: Futur en Seine Digital Festival
    13–23 June 2013 Paris, France

    Futur en Seine was created by Cap Digital in 2009, as a ten days festival presenting the latest digital innovations from France and around the world for professionals and the general public.

    The festival will start with the Innovations Village (exhibitions, conferences and workshops around innovative projects…) at CENTQUATRE centre from June 13th to 16th, 2013. It will continue all over Paris Region, with approximately one hundred partner events, until June 23rd 2013. Learn more.

    Opportunity: Grand Challenges Explorations

    One bold idea. That’s all it takes. Unorthodox thinking is essential to overcoming the most persistent challenges in global health. Vaccines were first developed over 200 years ago because revolutionary thinkers took an entirely new approach to preventing disease.

    Grand Challenges Explorations fosters innovation in global health research. The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation has committed $100 million to encourage scientists worldwide to expand the pipeline of ideas to fight our greatest health challenges.

    The grant program is open to anyone from any discipline, from student to tenured professor, and from any organization – colleges and universities, government laboratories, research institutions, non-profit organizations and for-profit companies. Click here to learn more.

    Opportunity: ‘ABI’ Change Agent Awards

    The Change Agent Awards celebrate the accomplishments of rising technical women leaders from outside the United States, with an emphasis on developing countries, whose work results in social, cultural, and/or behavioral change. Recipients are honored by the technical women’s community at the Grace Hopper Celebration. The award covers the winners’ expenses to attend the conference. Click here to learn more.

    Event: 2013 Inner City 100 Symposium: A Cast Of Urban Heros
    20–21 May 2013 Boston, United States

    Join the fastest-growing urban firms in America at the Inner City 100 Symposium to access the tools and know-how small businesses need to scale.

    The Inner City 100 Symposium will take place on May 20–21 at Harvard Business School and the Boston Park Plaza Hotel, where hundreds of high-growth small businesses from across the country will gather for a full day of cutting-edge management education and networking opportunities. Among the participants will be CEOs from the selected 100 fastest-growing urban businesses.

    The Symposium is the culmination of the Inner City 100 Program, a ranking of the fastest-growing companies located in America’s inner cities. This year’s event will feature case studies presented by Harvard Business School faculty and peer-to-peer workshops led by standout Inner City 100 CEOs. Learn more.

    Event: Webinar: Equity, Demography and the Future of the American Economy
    10 April 2013 Webex

    Advancing equity — just and fair inclusion into a society in which everyone can participate and prosper — has often been viewed separate from, or even opposed to, efforts to foster economic competiveness and efficiencies in the marketplace.

    This webinar makes the case that in light of the nation’s demographic transformation, pursuing strategies that create more inclusion are no longer only moral imperatives — they are economic ones. Presenters will share the latest on the demographic shifts changing the country and outline emerging research that makes the case that equity-driven growth and business development are fundamental to the nation’s economic future. Learn more.

    Opportunity: Intel for Change: Smart Girls = Smart World

    Intel believes education is a fundamental right for everyone. But in many parts of the world, girls continue to be disproportionately denied access to education.

    Let’s join together in a quest to ensure that the path to an education is open to everyone. We’re looking for three dynamic people to partner with us as members of the Intel® for Change team. This year each Intel for Change team will be sent to India, Kenya or Ecuador where you’ll spend ten transformative days working to make a real difference there on the ground. Teams will be tasked with delivering crucial information about education in these developing countries. After your return, you and your teammates will become the voice of change for girl’s education sharing your experiences via documentaries, essays, and speakerships arranged through the Intel for Change program. Click here to learn more about the contest.

    Event: Sankalp Forum
    17 April 2013 Mumbai, India

    Sankalp Forum’s annual summit was the first platform for social enterprises in India, and rapidly became the world’s largest. It is a convergence of global knowledge, investment and dialog geared towards building a more inclusive ecosystem for high impact, pro-poor businesses. Each year, it brings several social enterprises to the forefront, and connects them to enablers, mentors and crucial networks. In 2013, the Summit joined forces with Villgro’s Unconvention to consolidate the social enterprise space in India. Now called the Sankalp Unconvention Summit, it will be able to offer more new initiatives and focus more strongly on regional deep-dive. Learn more.

    Event: Global Forum on Innovation & Technology Entrepreneurship
    28–30 May 2013 East London, South Africa

    infoDev, a global innovation partnership within the World Bank, and South Africa’s Department of Science and Technology cordially invite you to the Global Forum on Innovation & Technology Entrepreneurship on May 28–30, 2013, in East London, South Africa. The Forum will take you on a journey into the world of learning, business matchmaking, strategy, and knowledge sharing, with a special focus on the needs of African innovators. Learn more.

    Event: African Perspectives 2013
    14–17 November 2013 Lagos, Nigeria

    African Perspectives is a series of conferences on Urbanism and Architecture in Africa, initiated by the Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology (Kumasi, Ghana), University of Pretoria (South Africa), Ecole Supérieure d’Architecture de Casablanca (Morocco), Ecole Africaine des Métiers de l’Architecture et de l’Urbanisme (Lomé, Togo), ARDHI University (Dar es Salaam, Tanzania), Delft University of Technology (Netherlands) and ArchiAfrika.

    The objectives of the African Perspectives conferences are:

    • to bring together major stakeholders to map out a common agenda for African Architecture and create a forum for its sustainable development
    • to provide the opportunity for African experts in Architecture to share locally developed knowledge and expertise with each other and the broader international community
    • to establish a network of African experts on sustainable building and built environments for future cooperation on research and development initiatives on the continent.

    Learn more.

    Event: 6th Making Cities Liveable Conference
    17–19 June 2013 Melbourne, Australia

    6th Making Cities Liveable Conference will be held in conjunction with the Sustainability Conference “SustainableTransformation” bringing a new era of collaboration, information sharing and professional networking.

    The conference is being held from the 17th–19th June 2013 at Novotel Melbourne St Kilda. The joint conference brings together National, State and Regional delegates to exchange ideas, discuss Business, Government and Community initiatives and examine opportunities in the sector, we hope you will join us. Learn more.

  • URBim | for just and inclusive cities

    Favela Orgânica (“Organic Favela”) is an initiative launched in late 2011 by Regina Tchelly, who decided to share her love of cooking while improving nutrition and sustainable food practices among favela residents in Rio de Janeiro. Tchelly’s specialty: the use of natural ingredients that people generally discard, such as banana, watermelon, and passion fruit peels, carrot leaves, and cauliflower and broccoli stalks. Weekly workshops held in Morro da Babilônia, the favela in southern Rio de Janeiro where Tchelly lives, combine instruction in cooking, sustainable urban agriculture, and composting practices with meals featuring tasty, healthy dishes like watermelon peel risotto and banana and passion fruit peel cake. Learn more.

    Submitted by Catalina Gomez — Wed, 10/17/2012 – 01:00

    Among Latin American countries, Brazil has led the way in addressing climate change in the region, notably by creating a national public policy framework to guide priorities and interventions in the field. Some of the most relevant advances include the approval of the National Policy on Climate Change in 2009. In the same year, a National Fund for Climate Change was established allowing the allocation of resources for climate change adaptation and mitigation initiatives. Brazil has also moved forward in reducing the deforestation process of the Amazon forest and has been successful in developing and expanding the use biofuels, areas that have placed the country in the global sustainability spotlight. Learn more.

    Submitted by Catalina Gomez — Wed, 10/10/2012 – 01:00

    O Museu de Favela – MUF é uma associação privada sem fins lucrativos, de interesse cultural e comunitário que atua no museu territorial integral formado pelas favelas Pavão, Pavãozinho e Cantagalo. Desde sua criação em 2008 o MUF desenvolve processos museais experimentais de modos de trabalho inusitados, plantando novos paradigmas no campo da museologia social brasileira. A visão de futuro é transformar aquelas favelas em monumento turístico carioca. A missão do MUF é realizar tal visão de futuro, transformadora de condições de vida local, através da cultura, e demonstrar que a solução de inclusão funcional urbana e socioeconômica sustentável de favelas deve partir de dentro delas.

    Submitted by Catalina Gomez — Sun, 10/07/2012 – 01:00

    In little more than a decade, Catalytic Communities has become an active voice in promoting a more educated understanding of Rio de Janeiro’s favelas. CatComm (as it is usually called), a nonprofit organization established in Rio in 2000, aims to integrate the favelas into the wider society and generate greater knowledge about their rich cultural and social value. To accomplish these goals, it actively promotes capacity-building initiatives among low-income community leaders and youth, as well as conducting neighborhood visits and research. Read and discuss.

    Submitted by Catalina Gomez — Fri, 09/28/2012 – 01:00

    Brazil’s fight against HIV/AIDS has been widely recognized as a success story. In the course of the worldwide, thirty-year battle against the epidemic, this country has managed to control the spread of HIV/AIDS with highly active and open preventive campaigns while providing universal access to treatment to all HIV/AIDS patients. The most important aspects of Brazil’s success in fighting the epidemic have been, first, the government’s strong leadership and support to HIV/AIDS programs, at both the national and the municipal levels; second, the active mobilization of civil society and non-governmental organizations, which have helped to promote support at the local level. Read and discuss.

    Submitted by Catalina Gomez — Thu, 09/13/2012 – 01:00

    Until very recently, only the better-off neighborhoods in Rio were able to explore local cultural life and entertainment options online. Today, however, it’s possible to get updated and geo-referenced information about the region’s history and cultural life, as well as where to shop and eat in some of the city’s poorest neighborhoods — such Complexo da Mare, Complexo do Alemão, Santa Marta, Pavão Pavozinho, and Cidade de Deus. All this is possible thanks to an initiative called Wikimapa, created in 2009 by Rede Jovem, an organization that has been working for more than 12 years to promote social inclusion among low-income adolescents though the use of technology. Read and discuss.

    Submitted by Catalina Gomez — Tue, 09/04/2012 – 01:00

    Vidigal, a low-income neighborhood in Rio de Janeiro’s Zona Sul, is enjoying an important economic and cultural transformation. One of the most inspiring projects contributing to that change is Sitiê, an initiative started by three neighborhood residents who decided to recover 300 square meters of a former garbage dump and transform it into a park. Sitiê has expanded, with a small orchid vivarium and a room for recycling trash; the most impressive thing about this initiative, however, is that it is based entirely on neighborhood support and collaboration. Read and discuss.

    Submitted by Catalina Gomez — Fri, 08/31/2012 – 01:00

    Seeking to address a growing need for vocational education in the favelas and to reduce the digital divide between the formal and informal city, the Developing Minds Foundation (DMF) has been working in Cidade de Deus, Rocinha, and Mangueira since 2006, partnering closely with local community-based organizations to apply their extensive knowledge of each neighborhood’s conditions and needs. Learn more.

    Submitted by Catalina Gomez — Sat, 08/25/2012 – 01:00

    It has been hard to miss Rio de Janeiro’s changing approach to public security — the “pacification” of urban territories previously governed by drug-trafficking organizations. In just under four years, Rio’s policia de pacificação (“pacification police”) have installed 26 pacification police units, affecting more than 300,000 people, in the low-income favelas where state presence has always been tenuous. The permanent presence of the police denotes a new kind of governance that provides public services to what were once deemed ‘illegal’ communities — which not only has enhanced feelings of security, but also has fostered greater connectivity between the oft-excluded poor and the state, reducing urban disparity in the process. Learn more.

    Submitted by Graham Denyer Willis — Sun, 08/12/2012 – 01:00

    Rio de Janeiro’s informal settlements, or favelas, have enormous infrastructure gaps that range from the need for better roads and sewage systems to lack of access to water and electricity. In 2010, Rio’s Municipal Housing Secretariat launched a new municipal upgrading program, known as Morar Carioca, at an estimated total cost of US$4 billion, aiming to urbanize some 250 of Rio’s favelas through 2020 as part of the legacy of the 2016 Olympics. Such a goal seems idealistic, but given the city’s operational experience in the implementation of Favela Bairro, it may actually be achieved. Learn more.

    Submitted by Catalina Gomez — Thu, 08/09/2012 – 01:00

  • URBim | for just and inclusive cities

    Individuals, organizations, and governments around the world are developing creative ways to promote and uphold the 30 articles of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. In recognition of Human Rights Day on December 10th, this conversation highlights solutions to issues ranging from discrimination against refugees to lack of access to sanitation. These solutions — which include online monitoring systems, a thriller feature film, in-home toilets, and activist photography — raise awareness and provide much-needed services for vulnerable communities. Read on to find out more about these initiatives from Nairobi, Jakarta, Dhaka, and Mumbai, and then share your thoughts in the discussion below.

    Katy Fentress, Nairobi Community Manager

    The September 2013 Westgate crisis was the most recent in a slew of attacks that have rocked Kenya since it began military operations in Somalia two years ago.

    The blame for this and previous attacks has generally been pinned on the Islamist group Al Shabaab, who claim to be retaliating against what for them is an unjust invasion and occupation of their country.

    While Eastleigh, a neighborhood in the east of Nairobi that houses most of the city’s Somali immigrants, has borne the brunt of most of these attacks, residents have also experienced a rise in hostility from local Kenyans and harassment at the hands of the police.

    Somalis in Nairobi live as urban refugees escaping from harsh realities back home. In their daily lives they invariably are affected to some degree by three overwhelming challenges. These, according to Kenyan-based film producer Vincenzo Cavallo, are discrimination, corruption, and terrorism.

    In an attempt to address these three symbiotic challenges, a movie is currently being produced by Cultural Video Foundation (CVF), a Nairobi-based film production company that is run by Cavallo and fellow-filmmaker Alessandra Argenti, with the support of an Italian NGO called the International Committee for the Development of Peoples (CISP) and funding from the European Union.

    The aim of the film, named Wazi FM, is to speak out about discrimination against Somali refugees at the hands of police and the connection between this and the rise in terrorist attacks. The film also attempts to send a message on the topic of corruption, as it highlights how it is this widespread practice that allows terrorists to cross the border into the Kenya in the first place.

    In Cavallo’s view, in order to prevent future terrorist attacks in Kenya and Somalia, it is essential to find a way for refugee communities and the police to work together on reporting suspicious activities and building trust where at the moment there is none.

    With Wazi FM, CVF has attempted to create a Kenyan Somali thriller. Filmed entirely in one location, the film is, according to Cavallo, a surreal take on the genre and one that aims to compete with commercial productions by providing the public with a breathtaking and compelling story.

    The aim of the production is to speak to both Kenyans and Somalis about how it is corruption and not immigration that is the main cause of insecurity in the country. Allowing Kenyan authorities to keep on with the extortion, harassment, and targeting of Somalis residents only serves to increasingly marginalize them and to create fertile territory where would-be terrorists and attackers can operate.

    Wazi FM was initially conceived as a twelve-episode TV series. Unfortunately, due to budgetary constraints, this was later cut down to a one-off feature film. CVF remains optimistic that they will succeed in broadening the reach of the show and that at some point it will be picked up by a local television channel brave enough to broadcast such a controversial message, or by an international distributor that is keen on covering sensitive topics of this kind.

    Countries like Kenya that have signed the United Nations International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights are required to uphold the rights of all people to liberty and security of person. They are also expected to guarantee non-discriminatory minority rights and equality before the law. It is thus imperative that the issue of corruption be adequately addressed both from the bottom up and through institutional processes, in order to guarantee that Kenyan citizens of Somali origin, and Somalis who are living in Kenya, are not subjected to discrimination on the part of those who are tasked with upholding their rights.

    Photo credit: Lorenzo Misselari

    Widya Anggraini, Jakarta Community Manager

    Undang-undang Dasar 1945 Indonesia secara resmi menjamin kebebasan memilih dan mempraktekkan agama dan kepercayaan tiap-tiap penduduk. Namun demikian pemerintah secara resmi mengakui hanya enam agama yaitu Islam, katolik, protestan, buddha, hindu dan konghuchu. akibatnya banyak terjadi kasus kekerasan terhadap minoritas penganut agama dan kepercayaan. Munculnya kelompok-kelompok militan islam misalnya, kerap melakukan intimidasi dan menyerang rumah-rumah ibadah serta anggota-anggota minoritas agama. Human Rights Watch yang sudah melakukan riset di 10 provinsi dan mewawancarai lebih dari 115 orang dari berbagai kepercayaan, menyatakan bahwa 71 diantara mereka adalah korban kekerasan dan pelanggaran. Begitu juga survey dari LSI yang menyatakan bahwa sejak kepemimpinan SBY tahun jumlah kekerasan diskriminasi meningkat dengan rata-rata 150 kasus pertahun dan 65 persen diantaranya adalah kekerasan agama.Dalam rangka menjaga keharmonisan dan keselarasan kehidupan beragama di Indonesia maka telah dikembangkan perangkat lunak yang dapat memonitor berbagai tindak kekerasan atas nama agama dan isu-isu pluralisme. Perangkat ini telah dikembangkan oleh dua institute di Jakarta, The Wahid Institute dan Setara Institute.

    The Wahid Institute (WI) berdiri tahun 2004 yang dibentuk sebagai upaya menyebarkan pemikiran islam moderat mantan presiden RI K.H Abdurrahman Wahid dalam mendorong terciptanya demokrasi, multikulturalisme dan toleransi baik di Indonesia maupun di dunia. Beberapa program yang menjadi wilayah kerja WI adalah advokasi kebijakan publik dan minoritas; kampanye islam demokrasi dan pluralisme; pemberdayaan akar rumput; serta monitoring isu keagamaan. Dalam hal monitoring isu keagaan ini WI telah mengembangkan pernangkat lunak untuk memantau isu-isu kekerasan dan konflik atas nama agama bernama Pemantauan Kebebasan Beragama dan Berkeyakinan. Kategori yang terangkum dalam perangkat tersebut termasuk diantaranya intoleransi dan diskriminasi atas dasar agama; kemajuan jaminan perlindungan kebebasan beragama/berkeyakinan serta pelanggaran kebebasan beragama/berkeyakinan. Jadi pada dasarnya perangkat ini bukan hanya melaporkan tindak kekerasan dan pelanggaran dalam beragama namun juga mencatat inisiatif-inisiatif masyarakat yang berupaya melindungi kebebasan masyarakat dalam beragama dan berkeyakinan.

    Perangkat serupa juga dikembangkan oleh Setara Institute yang mendesain Case Tracking System (CTS) untuk memantau pelanggaran kebebasan beragama/berkeyakinan di Indonesia. CTS merupakan bagian dari upaya Setara Institute untuk medorong terciptanya kondisi politik yang terbuka berdasar penghormatan atas keberagaman, pembelaan hak-hak manusia dan penghapusan sikap intoleran. Dalam form pelaporan CTS ini disebutkan kontak data pelapor, nama peristiwa, waktu dan tempat kejadian, korban, kerugian, pelaku baik negara maupun non-negara. Semua laporan masyarakat akan dikompilasi dan diolah menjadi data yang bisa diakses umum. Setiap tahun Setara Institute akan melakukan update berbagai bentuk dan jumlah tindakan pelanggaran, sebaran waktunya, grafik korban dan pelaku pelanggaran, serta jenis undang-undang yang dilanggar. Lebih jauh lagi, informasi dari CTS tersebut akan digunakan sebagai bahan laporan tentang kebebasan beragama (Report on Freedom of Religion and Belief) yang dikeluarkan setiap tahunnya serta sebagai materi penyusunan indeks kinerja penegakan HAM (Human Rights Enforcement Performance Index).

    Secara keseluruhan kedua perangkat yang diciptakan WI dan Setara Institute diharapkan akan memberikan gambaran tingkat toleransi masyarakat terhadap kebebasan beragama dan berkeyakinan serta menjadi alat advokasi bagi pemerintah untuk mengeluarkan kebijakan yang melindungi kelompok agama minoritas.

    Foto: Muslim Academy

    Widya Anggraini, Jakarta Community Manager

    Since 1945, Indonesia’s constitution formally guarantees the freedom of each citizen to choose and practice their own religion and beliefs. However, the government only officially recognizes six religions: Islam, Catholicism, Protestantism, Buddhism, Hinduism, and Confucianism – consequently giving rise to cases of violence against minority religions and faiths. The emergence of militant Islamic groups, for example, has often been responsible for intimidation and attacks of places of worship as well as members of religious minorities. The Human Rights Watch, which did research in ten provinces and interviewed over 115 people from different faith, stated that 71 of those interviewed were victims of violence and abuse. Another survey from LSI stated that since the current president’s election in 2004, violent discrimination has seen an increase of an average of 150 cases per year, with 65 percent of such cases being those of religious violence. In an effort to maintain the peace and harmonization of religious lives in Indonesia, two software initiatives have been developed to monitor various acts of violence related to religion and pluralistic issues – one by the Wahid Institute and the other by the Setara Institute.

    The Wahid Institute (WI) was founded in 2004 to spread the moderate Islamic beliefs of former Indonesian president Abdurahman Wahid, who believed in fostering democracy, multiculturalism, and tolerance in Indonesia and the world. Several programs undertaken by the WI include advocating public policy and minorities, campaigning Islamic democracy and pluralism, grassroots empowerment, as well as monitoring religious issues. In regards to the latter, WI has developed the “Monitoring the Freedom of Religion and Beliefs” software to monitor acts of religious violence and conflict. The categories contained within the software include intolerance and discrimination based on religion, promoting the guarantee of protection offered to religions/ beliefs, as well as the violation of freedoms of religions/beliefs. In sum, this device does not only report acts of religious violence, but also notes community initiatives that seek to protect the freedoms of the public to practice their religions and beliefs.

    A similar device, named the Case Tracking System (CTS), was developed by the Setara Institute to monitor violations of religious freedoms. The CTS is part of the efforts of the institute to endorse the creation of open political conditions based on respect for diversity, the defense of human rights, and the elimination of intolerant attitudes. The CTS report form contains contact details, the name of the event, the time and place of the incidents, the victims, the losses incurred, and both the positive and negative contributors to the incidents. All community reports are compiled and processed into data that can be accessed by the public. Every year, the Setara Institute will update the numbers and various types of violations, the distribution of time in between each, the graphs depicting offenders and victims, and the types of laws that were violated. Furthermore, information derived from the CTS will be used as material for reports on religious freedom (Report on Freedom of Religion and Belief) that will be issued each year, as well as for the preparation of the HAM index (Human Rights Enforcement Performance Index).

    All in all, both devices developed by the WI and the Setara Institute are expected to serve as both an overview of the level of community tolerance towards religious freedom, and as an advocacy tool for the government to issue laws and policies that will protect members of religious minorities.

    Photo: Muslim Academy

    লেখকঃ সায়মা সুলতানা জবা, অনুবাদকঃ ফারজানা নওশিন

    সব শহরকেই সংখ্যালঘু জাতিদের নিয়ে বিভিন্ন সমস্যার (যেমনঃ সংখ্যালঘুদের অসহযোগীতা) মোকাবেলা করতে হয়, কিন্তু সবাইকে মানবাধিকার লঙ্ঘন সংক্রান্ত সমস্যা এরকম নাটকীয় ভাবে সমাধান করতে বাধ্য হতে হয় না যেমন ভাবে বাংলাদেশ সরকারকে রোহিঙ্গা সম্প্রদায়ের সমস্যা মোকাবেলা করা হচ্ছে। রোহিঙ্গা সম্প্রদায় পশ্চিম মায়ানমারের উত্তর আরকান প্রদেশের সংখ্যালঘু মুসলিম জাতি। ১৯৭৮ সালে মায়ানমার সরকার থেকে তাদের নাগরিকত্ব অস্বীকার করা হয়েছে এবং গত দশ বছরে তারা বিভিন্ন ভাবে ধর্মীয় বৈষম্য এবং মানবাধিকার লঙ্ঘনের শিকার হয়েছে। ২০১২ সালে মায়ানমার বাংলাদেশ বর্ডার বন্ধ করে দেয়ার আগে অনেক রোহিঙ্গা তাদের প্রতিবেশী দেশ বাংলাদেশে নিরাপদ আশ্রয়ের জন্য চলে এসেছে। বর্তমানে প্রায় ২৯০০০ রোহিঙ্গা দক্ষিণ-পূর্ব বাংলাদেশে দুটি ক্যাম্পে রক্ষিত এবং অনুমিত প্রায় ২০০০০০ অনিবন্ধিত রোহিঙ্গা ক্যাম্পের আশেপাশে বিভিন্ন গ্রামে বাস করছে। এই এলাকার উচ্চ দারিদ্র, নিরক্ষরতা এবং কর্মহীনতার হার উদ্বাস্তুদের প্রতি বাংলাদেশীদের একটি বর্ধনশীল শত্রুতা তৈরি করছে। বাংলাদেশ সরকারের মতে মানবাধিকার রক্ষা সংস্থাগুলো শুধু আরো রোহিঙ্গাদের বাংলাদেশে আসার সুযোগ তৈরি করে দিচ্ছে।

    রোহিঙ্গা উদ্বাস্তুদের প্রতি ঢাকাভিত্তিক সরকারি প্রতিদ্বন্দ্বিতার মুখে কিছু সৃষ্টিশীল সচেতনতামূলক পদক্ষেপ নেয়া হয়েছে। বিশেষ করে ফটোগ্রাফির মাধ্যমেএকটি বিশাল প্রচারণা শুরু হয়েছে ঢাকা, বাংলাদেশের অন্যান্য অঞ্চল এবং সারা বিশ্বের মানুষের জন্য, এটি দেখানর জন্য যে রোহিঙ্গা কারা এবং এদের অধিকার রক্ষার জন্য কি করা যেতে পারে ।

    বাংলাদেশের প্রায় সব রাজনৈতিক, অর্থনৈতিক এবং সংবাদমাধ্যমের মতে ঢাকা মানবাধিকার লঙ্ঘনের প্রতিবাদের জন্য আন্তর্জাতিক সম্প্রদায়ের কাছে একটি শক্তিশালী স্থান। প্রামানিক আলোকচিত্রী সাইফুল হক অমি ঢাকার বাইরে কাজ করেন এবং ২০০৯ সাল থেকে তিনি রোহিঙ্গা সমস্যার প্রতি মনোনিবেশ করেন। অমি নিজেকে একজন আলোকচিত্রী বলার চেয়ে সামাজিক কর্মী হিসাবে বর্ণনা করেন। এখন পর্যন্ত তিনি “বাংলাদেশে আড়ম্বরহীন রোহিঙ্গা শরণার্থী বর্জন ও অস্বীকার” নামে একটি আলকচিত্রের প্রদর্শনী করেছেন। অমি বাংলাদেশের শরণার্থী শিবিরের এই সকল ছবি ব্যবহার করেন উদবাস্তু মানুষের জীবনের কাহিনী তুলে ধরার জন্য যারা নিজেরা নিজেদের কষ্টের কথা বলতে পারে না। উদাহরণস্বরূপ, সাম্প্রতিককালে তিনি এশিয়ান ইউনিভার্সিটি ফর উইমেন-এ (যেখানে ১৪ টি দেশের মেয়েরা পড়াশোনা করছে) তার রোহিঙ্গা শিবিরের আলোকচিত্রগুলো দেখান এবং বর্ণনা করেন যে কেন রোহিঙ্গা শরণার্থীদের সাহায্য করা গুরুত্বপূর্ণ এবং কেন এখানে আন্তর্জাতিক সাহায্য প্রয়োজন।

    অমির কাজ দেখায় যে রোহিঙ্গাদের মানবাধিকার রক্ষা একটি চরম অস্বীকৃত সমস্যা এবং শহর কেন্দ্রিক এই প্রচারণা প্রমান করে যে এটির দ্রুত সমাধান জরুরি, যদিও এই প্রচারণা এখনো সরকারের সিদ্ধান্তের বিরধিতা করতে রোহিঙ্গাদের উপর উপযুক্ত রাজনৈতিক মনোযোগ আকর্ষণ করতে পারে নি। তারপরও সৃজনশীল উপায়ে রোহিঙ্গা সমস্যার সমাধানের চেষ্টা, যা অনেক নাগরিকদের দৃষ্টি আকর্ষণ করে, একটি গুরুত্বপূর্ণ পদক্ষেপ। বিশ্বের সকল আলোকচিত্রীরা এবং অন্যান্য মিডিয়ার সদস্যরা তাদের গৃহীত আলোকচিত্রসমূহ অন্যান্য প্রমান প্রদর্শনীর মাধ্যমে সংখ্যালঘু জাতিদের প্রতি বৈষম্যর বিরুদ্ধে কাজ করতে পারে যখন সরকার নীরব থাকে।

    Photo credits: Saiful Huq Omi

    Saima Sultana Jaba, Dhaka Community Manager

    Nearly all cities deal with the issue of incorporating ethnic minorities, but not many are forced to deal with a human rights violation as dramatic as the treatment of the Rohingya community in Bangladesh. The Rohingya are a Muslim ethnic minority from the northern Arkan state of western Myanmar. In 1978, they were denied their citizenship by the Myanmar state, and in recent decades they have faced religious discrimination and widespread human rights violations. Many Rohingya fled into neighboring Bangladesh for safety, until the Bangladesh government closed its borders in 2012. At present, nearly 29,000 Rohingya refugees reside in two camps in south-eastern Bangladesh, and the government has estimated that another 200,000 unregistered refugees live in villages outside of these camps. The high rates of poverty, illiteracy, and unemployment in this district have contributed to a growing Bangladeshi hostility towards the refugees, and the Bangladesh government has argued that humanitarian aid organizations only create a ‘pull factor’ for more Rohingya to enter Bangladesh.

    In the face of such government antagonism toward the Rohingya refugees, some creative awareness-raising initiatives have recently emerged. Photography, in particular, has been marshalled to create wide-reaching campaigns aimed at showing citizens in Dhaka, throughout Bangladesh, and in other regions of the world just who the Rohingya are and what can be done to promote their rights.

    As the hub of nearly all political, economic, and media outlets of Bangladesh, Dhaka is a powerful place to portray human rights violations to the international community. Documentary photographer Saiful Huq Omi works out of Dhaka and began to focus on the Rohingya issue in 2009. Rather than describing himself as a photographer, Omi explains that he is an activist. To this end, he has toured with a photography campaign entitled, “The Disowned and the Denied: Stateless Rohingya Refugees in Bangladesh.” Omi uses his photos from Bangladesh refugee camps to capture the stories of people who have been deemed ‘voiceless’, and to share these stories. This fall, for instance, he gave a talk to university students from fourteen different countries at the Asian University for Women in Bangladesh, in which he used his photographs to describe the plight of the Rohingya and the importance of international campaigns to support their need for statehood.

    Omi’s work shows how, especially for a human rights issue as extreme and unacknowledged as that of the Rohingyas, urban-based, creative awareness campaigns can be vital for emphasizing urgency and fostering change. Such campaigns have not yet given the Rohingya issue in Bangladesh sufficient political attention to hold the government accountable for its actions or to force needed collaboration between NGOs in the national and international sectors. Yet creative efforts to raise awareness and put a personalized face on an issue that is obscure to many citizens are a crucial first step to addressing such complicated human rights violations. Like photographers and members of the media in Dhaka, artists in other cities around the world can play a powerful role in initiating change by speaking out and providing visual material to document abuse towards minorities when the government is silent.

    Photo credits: Saiful Huq Omi

    Carlin Carr, Mumbai Community Manager

    At a recent sanitation roundtable discussion at the Observer Research Foundation (ORF), a public policy think tank in Mumbai, Chairman Sudheendra Kulkarni said that Mahatma Gandhi believed sanitation was more important than political independence. In 2010, the UN declared access to sanitation a human right. Despite the increased emphasis, says Dhaval Desai, a senior researcher at ORF, the two are rarely linked. “If one agrees that there is a connect between lack of access to clean and hygienic sanitation and global statistics on poverty, malnutrition, infant mortality, maternal health, diseases, education, and gender, then it is impossible to deny sanitation as an intrinsic human rights issue.” Desai, who specializes in water and sanitation issues, discussed with us the importance of this human rights issue and some promising ways forward.

    What is the current situation in Mumbai?

    The current situation in Mumbai is as bad as it is in the rest of India. Media reports quoting Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (MCGM) data have shown recently that Mumbai has a provision of 10,381 public toilet facilities for its total population of nearly 13 million. Thus, against the WHO norms of availability of one toilet seat per 50 people, Mumbai has one toilet seat per 1,200 people. The situation is worse when you look at availability of public conveniences for women. Only 3,181 toilet seats of the total are for women, giving a ratio of one toilet seat per 1,800 women.

    Can you paint us a picture of what a typical slum dweller deals with each day in this regard?

    The situation is not as bad for men as it is for women and young girls. With a poor ratio of toilet seats to population, it is common to find long queues of men and women — with dabbas (water cans) in their hands, since many toilets do not have any running water — outside community toilet blocks, waiting for their turn. Many have to walk long distances from their homes to reach the toilet block.

    But this is only in slums where the toilets are maintained well and are usable. The condition of many community toilets is so pathetic that they are simply unusable. It is in such slums where open defecation is actually the preferred option. But this is also where the women and young girls become most vulnerable and are forced to venture out for their daily ablutions, looking for secluded spots in the neighbourhood under the cover of darkness. For the children, on the other hand, defecating in the open is an extremely common phenomenon, just a ‘way of life’.

    You recently held a roundtable discussion on sanitation at ORF Mumbai and came to a consensus that every home should have a toilet rather than community toilets. Why this is the best option and is it feasible?

    Access to toilets inside slum homes is the best and possibly the easiest and most scalable of options. There are examples of slum pockets across Mumbai where toilets do exist inside homes, and each of these slums tells an inspiring story of how toilets have actually brought about a silent social revolution in the lives of the residents. All of these toilets are as well-maintained as one can find in any good corporate office or an affluent home. The only difference is that these toilets and bathrooms do not have ‘designer’ fittings and toiletries.

    Slum improvement programs undertaken by organizations like Shelter Associates, a Pune-based NGO, on behalf of the State Government in the towns of Sangli and Miraj have also focused on provision of toilets inside homes as being the easiest and most feasible option.

    Could you tell us about one or two interesting sanitation initiatives in Mumbai?

    The Tulshetpada slum in Bhandup, a northern suburb of Mumbai, has witnessed a silent social revolution thanks to provision of toilets inside homes, by far the most striking sanitation initiative in the city. The other amazing success story is of the community toilet run by a community-based organization called Triratna Prerana Mandal (TPM) in the western Mumbai suburb of Santacruz. TPM took over the management of the toilet in 2001 under the MCGM’s Slum Sanitation Program, but has taken this work to high levels of social transformation. They run a self-help group for women, offer vocational training to the youth of the slum, run computer training classes on the terrace of the toilet, which also has a community kitchen preparing midday meals for 3,000 school children. The toilet gets all its water from a rainwater harvesting system and is powered 100 percent by solar energy. TPM’s community toilet is a glorious example of a toilet’s power of transformation. If only Mumbai can have hundreds more Tulshetpadas and TPMs.

    Photo credit: CDC Foundation

  • URBim | for just and inclusive cities

    Individuals, organizations, and governments around the world are developing creative ways to promote and uphold the 30 articles of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. In recognition of Human Rights Day on December 10th, this conversation highlights solutions to issues ranging from discrimination against refugees to lack of access to sanitation. These solutions — which include online monitoring systems, a thriller feature film, in-home toilets, and activist photography — raise awareness and provide much-needed services for vulnerable communities. Read on to find out more about these initiatives from Nairobi, Jakarta, Dhaka, and Mumbai, and then share your thoughts in the discussion below.

    Katy Fentress, Nairobi Community Manager

    The September 2013 Westgate crisis was the most recent in a slew of attacks that have rocked Kenya since it began military operations in Somalia two years ago.

    The blame for this and previous attacks has generally been pinned on the Islamist group Al Shabaab, who claim to be retaliating against what for them is an unjust invasion and occupation of their country.

    While Eastleigh, a neighborhood in the east of Nairobi that houses most of the city’s Somali immigrants, has borne the brunt of most of these attacks, residents have also experienced a rise in hostility from local Kenyans and harassment at the hands of the police.

    Somalis in Nairobi live as urban refugees escaping from harsh realities back home. In their daily lives they invariably are affected to some degree by three overwhelming challenges. These, according to Kenyan-based film producer Vincenzo Cavallo, are discrimination, corruption, and terrorism.

    In an attempt to address these three symbiotic challenges, a movie is currently being produced by Cultural Video Foundation (CVF), a Nairobi-based film production company that is run by Cavallo and fellow-filmmaker Alessandra Argenti, with the support of an Italian NGO called the International Committee for the Development of Peoples (CISP) and funding from the European Union.

    The aim of the film, named Wazi FM, is to speak out about discrimination against Somali refugees at the hands of police and the connection between this and the rise in terrorist attacks. The film also attempts to send a message on the topic of corruption, as it highlights how it is this widespread practice that allows terrorists to cross the border into the Kenya in the first place.

    In Cavallo’s view, in order to prevent future terrorist attacks in Kenya and Somalia, it is essential to find a way for refugee communities and the police to work together on reporting suspicious activities and building trust where at the moment there is none.

    With Wazi FM, CVF has attempted to create a Kenyan Somali thriller. Filmed entirely in one location, the film is, according to Cavallo, a surreal take on the genre and one that aims to compete with commercial productions by providing the public with a breathtaking and compelling story.

    The aim of the production is to speak to both Kenyans and Somalis about how it is corruption and not immigration that is the main cause of insecurity in the country. Allowing Kenyan authorities to keep on with the extortion, harassment, and targeting of Somalis residents only serves to increasingly marginalize them and to create fertile territory where would-be terrorists and attackers can operate.

    Wazi FM was initially conceived as a twelve-episode TV series. Unfortunately, due to budgetary constraints, this was later cut down to a one-off feature film. CVF remains optimistic that they will succeed in broadening the reach of the show and that at some point it will be picked up by a local television channel brave enough to broadcast such a controversial message, or by an international distributor that is keen on covering sensitive topics of this kind.

    Countries like Kenya that have signed the United Nations International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights are required to uphold the rights of all people to liberty and security of person. They are also expected to guarantee non-discriminatory minority rights and equality before the law. It is thus imperative that the issue of corruption be adequately addressed both from the bottom up and through institutional processes, in order to guarantee that Kenyan citizens of Somali origin, and Somalis who are living in Kenya, are not subjected to discrimination on the part of those who are tasked with upholding their rights.

    Photo credit: Lorenzo Misselari

    Widya Anggraini, Jakarta Community Manager

    Undang-undang Dasar 1945 Indonesia secara resmi menjamin kebebasan memilih dan mempraktekkan agama dan kepercayaan tiap-tiap penduduk. Namun demikian pemerintah secara resmi mengakui hanya enam agama yaitu Islam, katolik, protestan, buddha, hindu dan konghuchu. akibatnya banyak terjadi kasus kekerasan terhadap minoritas penganut agama dan kepercayaan. Munculnya kelompok-kelompok militan islam misalnya, kerap melakukan intimidasi dan menyerang rumah-rumah ibadah serta anggota-anggota minoritas agama. Human Rights Watch yang sudah melakukan riset di 10 provinsi dan mewawancarai lebih dari 115 orang dari berbagai kepercayaan, menyatakan bahwa 71 diantara mereka adalah korban kekerasan dan pelanggaran. Begitu juga survey dari LSI yang menyatakan bahwa sejak kepemimpinan SBY tahun jumlah kekerasan diskriminasi meningkat dengan rata-rata 150 kasus pertahun dan 65 persen diantaranya adalah kekerasan agama.Dalam rangka menjaga keharmonisan dan keselarasan kehidupan beragama di Indonesia maka telah dikembangkan perangkat lunak yang dapat memonitor berbagai tindak kekerasan atas nama agama dan isu-isu pluralisme. Perangkat ini telah dikembangkan oleh dua institute di Jakarta, The Wahid Institute dan Setara Institute.

    The Wahid Institute (WI) berdiri tahun 2004 yang dibentuk sebagai upaya menyebarkan pemikiran islam moderat mantan presiden RI K.H Abdurrahman Wahid dalam mendorong terciptanya demokrasi, multikulturalisme dan toleransi baik di Indonesia maupun di dunia. Beberapa program yang menjadi wilayah kerja WI adalah advokasi kebijakan publik dan minoritas; kampanye islam demokrasi dan pluralisme; pemberdayaan akar rumput; serta monitoring isu keagamaan. Dalam hal monitoring isu keagaan ini WI telah mengembangkan pernangkat lunak untuk memantau isu-isu kekerasan dan konflik atas nama agama bernama Pemantauan Kebebasan Beragama dan Berkeyakinan. Kategori yang terangkum dalam perangkat tersebut termasuk diantaranya intoleransi dan diskriminasi atas dasar agama; kemajuan jaminan perlindungan kebebasan beragama/berkeyakinan serta pelanggaran kebebasan beragama/berkeyakinan. Jadi pada dasarnya perangkat ini bukan hanya melaporkan tindak kekerasan dan pelanggaran dalam beragama namun juga mencatat inisiatif-inisiatif masyarakat yang berupaya melindungi kebebasan masyarakat dalam beragama dan berkeyakinan.

    Perangkat serupa juga dikembangkan oleh Setara Institute yang mendesain Case Tracking System (CTS) untuk memantau pelanggaran kebebasan beragama/berkeyakinan di Indonesia. CTS merupakan bagian dari upaya Setara Institute untuk medorong terciptanya kondisi politik yang terbuka berdasar penghormatan atas keberagaman, pembelaan hak-hak manusia dan penghapusan sikap intoleran. Dalam form pelaporan CTS ini disebutkan kontak data pelapor, nama peristiwa, waktu dan tempat kejadian, korban, kerugian, pelaku baik negara maupun non-negara. Semua laporan masyarakat akan dikompilasi dan diolah menjadi data yang bisa diakses umum. Setiap tahun Setara Institute akan melakukan update berbagai bentuk dan jumlah tindakan pelanggaran, sebaran waktunya, grafik korban dan pelaku pelanggaran, serta jenis undang-undang yang dilanggar. Lebih jauh lagi, informasi dari CTS tersebut akan digunakan sebagai bahan laporan tentang kebebasan beragama (Report on Freedom of Religion and Belief) yang dikeluarkan setiap tahunnya serta sebagai materi penyusunan indeks kinerja penegakan HAM (Human Rights Enforcement Performance Index).

    Secara keseluruhan kedua perangkat yang diciptakan WI dan Setara Institute diharapkan akan memberikan gambaran tingkat toleransi masyarakat terhadap kebebasan beragama dan berkeyakinan serta menjadi alat advokasi bagi pemerintah untuk mengeluarkan kebijakan yang melindungi kelompok agama minoritas.

    Foto: Muslim Academy

    Widya Anggraini, Jakarta Community Manager

    Since 1945, Indonesia’s constitution formally guarantees the freedom of each citizen to choose and practice their own religion and beliefs. However, the government only officially recognizes six religions: Islam, Catholicism, Protestantism, Buddhism, Hinduism, and Confucianism – consequently giving rise to cases of violence against minority religions and faiths. The emergence of militant Islamic groups, for example, has often been responsible for intimidation and attacks of places of worship as well as members of religious minorities. The Human Rights Watch, which did research in ten provinces and interviewed over 115 people from different faith, stated that 71 of those interviewed were victims of violence and abuse. Another survey from LSI stated that since the current president’s election in 2004, violent discrimination has seen an increase of an average of 150 cases per year, with 65 percent of such cases being those of religious violence. In an effort to maintain the peace and harmonization of religious lives in Indonesia, two software initiatives have been developed to monitor various acts of violence related to religion and pluralistic issues – one by the Wahid Institute and the other by the Setara Institute.

    The Wahid Institute (WI) was founded in 2004 to spread the moderate Islamic beliefs of former Indonesian president Abdurahman Wahid, who believed in fostering democracy, multiculturalism, and tolerance in Indonesia and the world. Several programs undertaken by the WI include advocating public policy and minorities, campaigning Islamic democracy and pluralism, grassroots empowerment, as well as monitoring religious issues. In regards to the latter, WI has developed the “Monitoring the Freedom of Religion and Beliefs” software to monitor acts of religious violence and conflict. The categories contained within the software include intolerance and discrimination based on religion, promoting the guarantee of protection offered to religions/ beliefs, as well as the violation of freedoms of religions/beliefs. In sum, this device does not only report acts of religious violence, but also notes community initiatives that seek to protect the freedoms of the public to practice their religions and beliefs.

    A similar device, named the Case Tracking System (CTS), was developed by the Setara Institute to monitor violations of religious freedoms. The CTS is part of the efforts of the institute to endorse the creation of open political conditions based on respect for diversity, the defense of human rights, and the elimination of intolerant attitudes. The CTS report form contains contact details, the name of the event, the time and place of the incidents, the victims, the losses incurred, and both the positive and negative contributors to the incidents. All community reports are compiled and processed into data that can be accessed by the public. Every year, the Setara Institute will update the numbers and various types of violations, the distribution of time in between each, the graphs depicting offenders and victims, and the types of laws that were violated. Furthermore, information derived from the CTS will be used as material for reports on religious freedom (Report on Freedom of Religion and Belief) that will be issued each year, as well as for the preparation of the HAM index (Human Rights Enforcement Performance Index).

    All in all, both devices developed by the WI and the Setara Institute are expected to serve as both an overview of the level of community tolerance towards religious freedom, and as an advocacy tool for the government to issue laws and policies that will protect members of religious minorities.

    Photo: Muslim Academy

    লেখকঃ সায়মা সুলতানা জবা, অনুবাদকঃ ফারজানা নওশিন

    সব শহরকেই সংখ্যালঘু জাতিদের নিয়ে বিভিন্ন সমস্যার (যেমনঃ সংখ্যালঘুদের অসহযোগীতা) মোকাবেলা করতে হয়, কিন্তু সবাইকে মানবাধিকার লঙ্ঘন সংক্রান্ত সমস্যা এরকম নাটকীয় ভাবে সমাধান করতে বাধ্য হতে হয় না যেমন ভাবে বাংলাদেশ সরকারকে রোহিঙ্গা সম্প্রদায়ের সমস্যা মোকাবেলা করা হচ্ছে। রোহিঙ্গা সম্প্রদায় পশ্চিম মায়ানমারের উত্তর আরকান প্রদেশের সংখ্যালঘু মুসলিম জাতি। ১৯৭৮ সালে মায়ানমার সরকার থেকে তাদের নাগরিকত্ব অস্বীকার করা হয়েছে এবং গত দশ বছরে তারা বিভিন্ন ভাবে ধর্মীয় বৈষম্য এবং মানবাধিকার লঙ্ঘনের শিকার হয়েছে। ২০১২ সালে মায়ানমার বাংলাদেশ বর্ডার বন্ধ করে দেয়ার আগে অনেক রোহিঙ্গা তাদের প্রতিবেশী দেশ বাংলাদেশে নিরাপদ আশ্রয়ের জন্য চলে এসেছে। বর্তমানে প্রায় ২৯০০০ রোহিঙ্গা দক্ষিণ-পূর্ব বাংলাদেশে দুটি ক্যাম্পে রক্ষিত এবং অনুমিত প্রায় ২০০০০০ অনিবন্ধিত রোহিঙ্গা ক্যাম্পের আশেপাশে বিভিন্ন গ্রামে বাস করছে। এই এলাকার উচ্চ দারিদ্র, নিরক্ষরতা এবং কর্মহীনতার হার উদ্বাস্তুদের প্রতি বাংলাদেশীদের একটি বর্ধনশীল শত্রুতা তৈরি করছে। বাংলাদেশ সরকারের মতে মানবাধিকার রক্ষা সংস্থাগুলো শুধু আরো রোহিঙ্গাদের বাংলাদেশে আসার সুযোগ তৈরি করে দিচ্ছে।

    রোহিঙ্গা উদ্বাস্তুদের প্রতি ঢাকাভিত্তিক সরকারি প্রতিদ্বন্দ্বিতার মুখে কিছু সৃষ্টিশীল সচেতনতামূলক পদক্ষেপ নেয়া হয়েছে। বিশেষ করে ফটোগ্রাফির মাধ্যমেএকটি বিশাল প্রচারণা শুরু হয়েছে ঢাকা, বাংলাদেশের অন্যান্য অঞ্চল এবং সারা বিশ্বের মানুষের জন্য, এটি দেখানর জন্য যে রোহিঙ্গা কারা এবং এদের অধিকার রক্ষার জন্য কি করা যেতে পারে ।

    বাংলাদেশের প্রায় সব রাজনৈতিক, অর্থনৈতিক এবং সংবাদমাধ্যমের মতে ঢাকা মানবাধিকার লঙ্ঘনের প্রতিবাদের জন্য আন্তর্জাতিক সম্প্রদায়ের কাছে একটি শক্তিশালী স্থান। প্রামানিক আলোকচিত্রী সাইফুল হক অমি ঢাকার বাইরে কাজ করেন এবং ২০০৯ সাল থেকে তিনি রোহিঙ্গা সমস্যার প্রতি মনোনিবেশ করেন। অমি নিজেকে একজন আলোকচিত্রী বলার চেয়ে সামাজিক কর্মী হিসাবে বর্ণনা করেন। এখন পর্যন্ত তিনি “বাংলাদেশে আড়ম্বরহীন রোহিঙ্গা শরণার্থী বর্জন ও অস্বীকার” নামে একটি আলকচিত্রের প্রদর্শনী করেছেন। অমি বাংলাদেশের শরণার্থী শিবিরের এই সকল ছবি ব্যবহার করেন উদবাস্তু মানুষের জীবনের কাহিনী তুলে ধরার জন্য যারা নিজেরা নিজেদের কষ্টের কথা বলতে পারে না। উদাহরণস্বরূপ, সাম্প্রতিককালে তিনি এশিয়ান ইউনিভার্সিটি ফর উইমেন-এ (যেখানে ১৪ টি দেশের মেয়েরা পড়াশোনা করছে) তার রোহিঙ্গা শিবিরের আলোকচিত্রগুলো দেখান এবং বর্ণনা করেন যে কেন রোহিঙ্গা শরণার্থীদের সাহায্য করা গুরুত্বপূর্ণ এবং কেন এখানে আন্তর্জাতিক সাহায্য প্রয়োজন।

    অমির কাজ দেখায় যে রোহিঙ্গাদের মানবাধিকার রক্ষা একটি চরম অস্বীকৃত সমস্যা এবং শহর কেন্দ্রিক এই প্রচারণা প্রমান করে যে এটির দ্রুত সমাধান জরুরি, যদিও এই প্রচারণা এখনো সরকারের সিদ্ধান্তের বিরধিতা করতে রোহিঙ্গাদের উপর উপযুক্ত রাজনৈতিক মনোযোগ আকর্ষণ করতে পারে নি। তারপরও সৃজনশীল উপায়ে রোহিঙ্গা সমস্যার সমাধানের চেষ্টা, যা অনেক নাগরিকদের দৃষ্টি আকর্ষণ করে, একটি গুরুত্বপূর্ণ পদক্ষেপ। বিশ্বের সকল আলোকচিত্রীরা এবং অন্যান্য মিডিয়ার সদস্যরা তাদের গৃহীত আলোকচিত্রসমূহ অন্যান্য প্রমান প্রদর্শনীর মাধ্যমে সংখ্যালঘু জাতিদের প্রতি বৈষম্যর বিরুদ্ধে কাজ করতে পারে যখন সরকার নীরব থাকে।

    Photo credits: Saiful Huq Omi

    Saima Sultana Jaba, Dhaka Community Manager

    Nearly all cities deal with the issue of incorporating ethnic minorities, but not many are forced to deal with a human rights violation as dramatic as the treatment of the Rohingya community in Bangladesh. The Rohingya are a Muslim ethnic minority from the northern Arkan state of western Myanmar. In 1978, they were denied their citizenship by the Myanmar state, and in recent decades they have faced religious discrimination and widespread human rights violations. Many Rohingya fled into neighboring Bangladesh for safety, until the Bangladesh government closed its borders in 2012. At present, nearly 29,000 Rohingya refugees reside in two camps in south-eastern Bangladesh, and the government has estimated that another 200,000 unregistered refugees live in villages outside of these camps. The high rates of poverty, illiteracy, and unemployment in this district have contributed to a growing Bangladeshi hostility towards the refugees, and the Bangladesh government has argued that humanitarian aid organizations only create a ‘pull factor’ for more Rohingya to enter Bangladesh.

    In the face of such government antagonism toward the Rohingya refugees, some creative awareness-raising initiatives have recently emerged. Photography, in particular, has been marshalled to create wide-reaching campaigns aimed at showing citizens in Dhaka, throughout Bangladesh, and in other regions of the world just who the Rohingya are and what can be done to promote their rights.

    As the hub of nearly all political, economic, and media outlets of Bangladesh, Dhaka is a powerful place to portray human rights violations to the international community. Documentary photographer Saiful Huq Omi works out of Dhaka and began to focus on the Rohingya issue in 2009. Rather than describing himself as a photographer, Omi explains that he is an activist. To this end, he has toured with a photography campaign entitled, “The Disowned and the Denied: Stateless Rohingya Refugees in Bangladesh.” Omi uses his photos from Bangladesh refugee camps to capture the stories of people who have been deemed ‘voiceless’, and to share these stories. This fall, for instance, he gave a talk to university students from fourteen different countries at the Asian University for Women in Bangladesh, in which he used his photographs to describe the plight of the Rohingya and the importance of international campaigns to support their need for statehood.

    Omi’s work shows how, especially for a human rights issue as extreme and unacknowledged as that of the Rohingyas, urban-based, creative awareness campaigns can be vital for emphasizing urgency and fostering change. Such campaigns have not yet given the Rohingya issue in Bangladesh sufficient political attention to hold the government accountable for its actions or to force needed collaboration between NGOs in the national and international sectors. Yet creative efforts to raise awareness and put a personalized face on an issue that is obscure to many citizens are a crucial first step to addressing such complicated human rights violations. Like photographers and members of the media in Dhaka, artists in other cities around the world can play a powerful role in initiating change by speaking out and providing visual material to document abuse towards minorities when the government is silent.

    Photo credits: Saiful Huq Omi

    Carlin Carr, Mumbai Community Manager

    At a recent sanitation roundtable discussion at the Observer Research Foundation (ORF), a public policy think tank in Mumbai, Chairman Sudheendra Kulkarni said that Mahatma Gandhi believed sanitation was more important than political independence. In 2010, the UN declared access to sanitation a human right. Despite the increased emphasis, says Dhaval Desai, a senior researcher at ORF, the two are rarely linked. “If one agrees that there is a connect between lack of access to clean and hygienic sanitation and global statistics on poverty, malnutrition, infant mortality, maternal health, diseases, education, and gender, then it is impossible to deny sanitation as an intrinsic human rights issue.” Desai, who specializes in water and sanitation issues, discussed with us the importance of this human rights issue and some promising ways forward.

    What is the current situation in Mumbai?

    The current situation in Mumbai is as bad as it is in the rest of India. Media reports quoting Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (MCGM) data have shown recently that Mumbai has a provision of 10,381 public toilet facilities for its total population of nearly 13 million. Thus, against the WHO norms of availability of one toilet seat per 50 people, Mumbai has one toilet seat per 1,200 people. The situation is worse when you look at availability of public conveniences for women. Only 3,181 toilet seats of the total are for women, giving a ratio of one toilet seat per 1,800 women.

    Can you paint us a picture of what a typical slum dweller deals with each day in this regard?

    The situation is not as bad for men as it is for women and young girls. With a poor ratio of toilet seats to population, it is common to find long queues of men and women — with dabbas (water cans) in their hands, since many toilets do not have any running water — outside community toilet blocks, waiting for their turn. Many have to walk long distances from their homes to reach the toilet block.

    But this is only in slums where the toilets are maintained well and are usable. The condition of many community toilets is so pathetic that they are simply unusable. It is in such slums where open defecation is actually the preferred option. But this is also where the women and young girls become most vulnerable and are forced to venture out for their daily ablutions, looking for secluded spots in the neighbourhood under the cover of darkness. For the children, on the other hand, defecating in the open is an extremely common phenomenon, just a ‘way of life’.

    You recently held a roundtable discussion on sanitation at ORF Mumbai and came to a consensus that every home should have a toilet rather than community toilets. Why this is the best option and is it feasible?

    Access to toilets inside slum homes is the best and possibly the easiest and most scalable of options. There are examples of slum pockets across Mumbai where toilets do exist inside homes, and each of these slums tells an inspiring story of how toilets have actually brought about a silent social revolution in the lives of the residents. All of these toilets are as well-maintained as one can find in any good corporate office or an affluent home. The only difference is that these toilets and bathrooms do not have ‘designer’ fittings and toiletries.

    Slum improvement programs undertaken by organizations like Shelter Associates, a Pune-based NGO, on behalf of the State Government in the towns of Sangli and Miraj have also focused on provision of toilets inside homes as being the easiest and most feasible option.

    Could you tell us about one or two interesting sanitation initiatives in Mumbai?

    The Tulshetpada slum in Bhandup, a northern suburb of Mumbai, has witnessed a silent social revolution thanks to provision of toilets inside homes, by far the most striking sanitation initiative in the city. The other amazing success story is of the community toilet run by a community-based organization called Triratna Prerana Mandal (TPM) in the western Mumbai suburb of Santacruz. TPM took over the management of the toilet in 2001 under the MCGM’s Slum Sanitation Program, but has taken this work to high levels of social transformation. They run a self-help group for women, offer vocational training to the youth of the slum, run computer training classes on the terrace of the toilet, which also has a community kitchen preparing midday meals for 3,000 school children. The toilet gets all its water from a rainwater harvesting system and is powered 100 percent by solar energy. TPM’s community toilet is a glorious example of a toilet’s power of transformation. If only Mumbai can have hundreds more Tulshetpadas and TPMs.

    Photo credit: CDC Foundation

  • URBim | for just and inclusive cities

    Despite the Ministry of Housing revising the categories of urban poor (EWS) and low income (LIG) groups with annual incomes up to Rs 100,000 (USD 1800) and Rs 200,000 (USD 3600) per year respectively, the new estimates will still leave out 60% of Mumbai’s population from accessing the national government affordable housing programs.

    That is a hard measure to accept when the reality in Mumbai is that 2 in 3 people (or about 60%) live in substandard housing or lack security of tenure in current housing arrangements. What the policy measure doesn’t take into account the drastic economic differences between a city such as Mumbai where the policy has an exclusionary impact to a city such as Ludhiana, where over 60% of the population are included as they earn less than Rs 15,000 (USD 275) per month.

    Mumbai’s household monthly income by percentile; Indian Rupees /US Dollars

    90th earns Rs 60,000/USD 1050 65th earn Rs 30,000/USD 525 35th earns Rs 15,000/USD 275 (current government benchmark)

    20th earns Rs 10,000/USD 185

    Source: Centre for Monitoring the Indian Economy (CMIE) 2011-12
    mHS website to download the white paper

    Let’s see what a household in the 65th percentile earning Rs 30,000 ( USD 525) can afford on housing. International standards advise that one should not be paying more than 30% of household income on housing expenses (for monthly mortgage installments and even less for renters). This equates to less than Rs 9000 (USD 165) per month for renters. For homebuyers the maximum price of a house that they could afford is Rs 7.6 lakhs (USD 14,000)(assumes the household is taking a loan with a tenure of 12 years, and interest of 12% per annum from a housing finance company with subsidy).

    Clearly in a context of Mumbai, there is no housing supply at sub Rs 8 lakhs that I know of and I assume you would have to go further outside the city to access housing. For renters in this income bracket a household would have more options although it would probably easier for those looking for shared accommodation. For those in the bottom 20% with ability to give less than Rs 3000 (USD55) for rent, finding housing means moving to informal settlements in the heart of cities, and owning a home in not really an option. Many complex questions need to be discussed and answered. Is an absolute national measure fair? Where should we objectively set the bar on access to safe and quality housing. Which income groups should India’s affordable housing policy target in Mumbai to make it more inclusive? Which segments should the private sector target?

    The second question on what incentives the governments’ affordable housing program should offer to different income groups in the underserved housing population is the topic of another debate!

  • URBim | for just and inclusive cities

    Most measures of poverty applied in low- and middle-income nations are for absolute poverty. They do not concern themselves with inequality. But it is not possible to understand poverty and its consequences without an engagement with inequality and what underlies it. Studies of inequality, like studies of poverty, also focus on income. They show that economic growth is often associated with growing income inequality, as demands for skilled workers push up wages at the top end of the salary scale and the low-paid cannot keep up. However, economic recession is also difficult for unskilled workers, who often face greater competition from the numbers looking for work. Yet many of the most dramatic (and unjust) inequalities are in relation to the other deprivations — housing and living conditions, access to services, the rule of law, and voice. These are also reflected in the very large inequalities in health status and in premature mortality that Chapter 3 documented.

    It is clear that inequalities in access to infrastructure and services within cities also reflect inequalities in political power, voice, and capacity to hold government agencies to account and to access entitlements. In some nations, those living in settlements with no legal address cannot register as voters, while in most informal settlements residents face difficulties getting the official documents needed to get on the voter’s register, access entitlements, and hold government or private service providers to account. In all nations, the inequalities faced by those living in informal settlements are reinforced by the stigma associated with living in these neighbourhoods.

    Understanding these deprivations also requires attention to the spatial aspects of inequalities — i.e. inequalities between neighbourhoods and districts within cities; so often, the data collected on incomes, living conditions, or service provision is from too small a sample to show these spatial inequalities. An understanding of the many different factors that create or exacerbate inequality also means more routes by which inequality can be reduced.

    There are also other aspects of inequality that throw light on deprivation — for instance, inequalities in household assets or capital, or inequalities caused or exacerbated by social or political status and relations, including discrimination. An understanding of inequality also needs to consider the implications for low-income groups of a larger and wealthier elite with the city — for instance, as their demands and influences restructure cities (and city planning) to serve their priorities. They can separate themselves from ‘the poor’ through gated communities and highways that link their homes, places of work, and places for leisure.

    There are also some nations where governments have reduced some of the most profound inequalities among the urban population — for instance, through extending provision for water, sanitation, schools, and health care (and sometimes the rule of law) to a larger proportion of the low-income population, or through transfer payments that reach large sections of the low income population with supplements to their income, such as pensions, conditional cash transfers, and child allowances. Where these reach low-income groups, these certainly reduce absolute poverty — although they may not reduce income-inequality, as incomes may rise more among high-income groups. But these cash transfers also do nothing to address the inequalities in provision for infrastructure and services.

    Next: What We Have Learned

    Summarized from Urban Poverty in the Global South: Scale and Nature, by Diana Mitlin and David Satterthwaite, Routledge, January 25, 2013.

  • URBim | for just and inclusive cities

    Event: African Creative Economy Conference 2013
    6–9 October 2013 Cape Town, South Africa

    The African Creative Economy Conference (6–9 October 2013) is an unique opportunity to empower yourself in a three-day intensive programme of exchanging cutting-edge information and innovative ideas. It will focus on unlocking the potential of the continent’s creative industries (Africa’s share of the global creative economy is currently less than 1%) and leapfrogging into emerging high-growth sectors of the world economy. Learn more.

  • URBim | for just and inclusive cities

    Africa’s slums are growing at twice the rate of its cities. By some accounts, sub-Saharan Africa will have upwards of 332 million slum dwellers by 2015. While millions of dollars have been spent improving the conditions in Africa’s urban informal settlements and the lives of the people who live therein, overall these efforts have amounted to little more than a drop in the ocean. Join our six panelists to explore the options for stemming the growth of these sprawling settlements and improving conditions in those slums that already exist: Irene Karanja of Muungano Support Trust (SDI) (Kenya); Claudio Torres of the UN-HABITAT Participatory Slum Upgrading Unit (PSUP) (Kenya); architect, urban planner, and World Bank Municipal Development Program consultant Sara Candiracci (Mozambique); Aditya Kumar of the Community Organization Resource Centre (CORC) (SDI) (South Africa); Jhono Bennett of the University of Johannesburg (South Africa); and Marie Huchzermeyer of the University of the Witwatersrand (South Africa).

    Click on the pictures of the panelists to see each panelist’s perspective below.

    Executive Director of Muungano Support Trust, a secretariat of the Shack/Slum Dwellers International Federation (SDI) (Kenya)

    Over the last 25 years, slum dwellers from cities in Africa have successfully mobilized into collections of Federations of the Urban Poor.

    These federations have collected their own financial resources in the form of savings and data pools, creating citywide profiles and extensive slum censuses. Unknown to the world, slum federations have managed to produce a large volume of documented knowledge about themselves that has transformed how the government delivers important services to its poor citizens and how financial instruments can be innovated by financial institutions to serve the needs of the poor.

    Using data collected from the profiles and censuses, Muungano Support Trust, a local NGO working with the federation of Kenya, has provided advisory services to the Government of Kenya and the World Bank, in order to help them intervene and provide housing solutions to over 10,000 families in the Kibera and Mukuru areas of Nairobi.

    The trust has also worked with university planning schools from the local and international academia community to influence how transforming planning discourse can untrap informal human settlements from the snares of historically rigid city planning standards.

    The private sector has grand opportunities to turn urban poor communities into important players within the city. Financial resources from the poor are beginning to challenge and put pressure on the private sector to innovate solutions. Federations have interventions that are facilitating this to happen.

    Data collected by communities with the support and technical capacity of organizations such as Muungano Support Trust, shows that there is a missing link that government interventions are not able to fill and development assistance is failing to cover.

    Insecurity of tenure remains one of the biggest challenges to improving the lives of slum dwellers in Nairobi. The government needs to release land for human settlement, whether it be public, private, or contested. If this does not happen, development aid will continue to subsidize the costs required for technical services to innovate various kinds of solutions for what are essentially locked scenarios!

    Irene Karanja is the founding Executive Director of Muungano Support Trust (MuST), a secretariat of the Slum/Shack Dwellers Federation in Kenya. She is a specialist in participatory research, community organizing and capacity building for the urban poor. For over six years, she has transformed the use of participatory techniques for data collection into a major instrument for planning the upgrading of slums. She has organized a strong constituency of slum dwellers to assume leadership of these settlements through savings groups, housing cooperatives and women’s associations.

    Architect, UN-HABITAT Participatory Slum Upgrading Programme (PSUP) (Kenya)

    African countries represent the majority of the least developed countries (LCD). Taking into account the fact that in most of these countries, the urban population growth is expanding at a faster pace than the national one, it is important to make three considerations in answering the question: “What will it take to make slum upgrading work in African urban centres?”

    Governments should be prepared to ‘give away’. National and local governments should weigh out the costs and risks of perpetuating the status quo and should fulfill the right of adequate housing for all at a pace that copes with the increase in poor urban households. They should prioritise, for example, the free provision of land for the urban poor, in the understanding that there will be no real estate profit and that no particular individual will benefit — a challenging task in a context where African post-independence elites have generally improved their own lives with little regard to equity and social justice.

    Strategies for the provision of adequate housing for the urban poor should go beyond market logic. In trying to come up with housing strategies that appeal to investors, the focus has shifted from the upgrading of the slum dwellers’ living conditions to the beautification of particularly degraded areas. This unchaining of a series of transaction costs results in a gentrification process that relocates the problem without giving it a solution. Slum upgrading strategies should strictly be conceived through a human rights approach.

    Adequate housing strategies should trigger self-relief dynamics in overcoming poverty. The problem of urban poverty is too big to miss the opportunity to engage concerned communities in devising its solution. The Latin-American slum upgrading experience has demonstrated that giving the right initial impulse to poor urban communities actually encourages a progressive and proactive self-upgrading attitude in slum residents, reducing the need for government funds to improve the living conditions of the urban poor. A strong involvement of the community can also help to reduce the risk of benefiting the wrong people, a common shortfall in superficially planned slum upgrading interventions.

    Claudio Torres is an architect with 10 years experience in the field of slum upgrading and housing in an African context. His work has taken him from the slums of Nairobi to settlements in Somaliland and South Sudan where he has worked as an architect, monitoring and evaluation expert, project manager, and construction expert. Torres has worked extensively in Nairobi’s Mathare valley slum with the Italian NGO COOPI, helping to set up an office in the field from which he coordinated a series of different programs. He is currently a consultant for the Participatory Slum Upgrading Program (PSUP), a division of UN-Habitat.

    Architect, Urban Planner and Consultant, World Bank Municipal Development Program (Mozambique)

    Urbanization in Africa is growing and national governments and local authorities are faced with the challenge of guiding cities’ growth while dealing with other constraints, including limited financial resources; weak institutional, management, and technical capacities; lack of proper urban policies and financial mechanisms to mobilize and regulate investments.

    To strengthen the ability of African cities to generate wealth, prosperity, and economic and human development, national governments and local authorities need to define a clear vision for the future of their cities and their informal settlements.

    Cities must be seen and treated as complex organisms whose elements are interconnected. Informal settlements should be seen as an integral part of this organism, and not as a “sick body” to be fought. They constitute a precious resource for the city and its population and must be included in the urban grid.

    Each and every stakeholder, whether it be the national government, local authorities, civil society, the community, the private sector, or the donor community, have a role to play and must be partners in the development and implementation of this vision for the city. In particular, the active participation of the local community is essential in finding lasting solutions, and to guarantee ownership and sustainability, social cohesion, and integration.

    The implementation of comprehensive and integrated improvement plans in informal areas would be ideal; however, it takes a long time and requires considerable financial resources. Considering the constraints in local financial and institutional capabilities, it is preferable to adopt an incremental approach, whereby small-scale interventions are first envisioned and planned in an extensive development plan, and then are carried out gradually through community participation.

    Priority must be given to the improvement and provision of infrastructure, basic services, accessibility, safety, and the creation of economic opportunities. Concurrently, special attention should be given to outdoor public spaces, where a vital part of the community’s social, cultural, and economic activities is conducted. Improving these spaces would improve the framework of daily life and bring dignity, beauty, and utility to informal and poor areas with minimal resources.

    Sara Candiracci is an architect and urban planner with 10 years experience in the design, management, and implementation of several urban planning and slum upgrading projects in Latin America and Africa with different organizations including UN-Habitat, the Inter-American Development Bank, and various NGOs. She is now working at the Municipality of Maputo, Mozambique, as Urban Planning Advisor for the World Bank Municipal Development Program. She is also conducting her PhD research on the potential use of urban cultural heritage in urban regeneration and planning, considering Maputo as case of study.

    Deputy Director, Community Organisation Resource Centre (CORC), an affiliate of Shack/Slum Dwellers International (South Africa)

    Over the last 20 years, the South African government has been hailed as having the most progressive housing and poverty policy environments in the continent. Besides making welfare grants available to previously marginalized communities, it has made provisions to provide housing to any citizen earning under R3,500 ($350)/month.

    Although more than 2.3 million subsidized homes have been built across the country, the impacts of the housing policy have fallen short. Informal settlements have gone up by 900 percent (from 300 to 2,700) while there are an estimated 2.1 million people on the waiting list for state-subsidized housing.

    Realizing the constraints of the housing program, the State has rapidly shifted its emphasis to informal settlement upgrading. New regulatory frameworks like Outcome 8 have been developed to allow for provision of basic services and tenure rights.

    While the aims of Outcome 8 and its aligned policies have been well defined, in my view there are still gaps in addressing the bigger issues. Firstly, how incremental informal settlement upgrading is implemented must be defined: are we trying to address tenure rights or basic services, land or housing, dependency on the state or self-reliance through livelihoods? Secondly, there is the manner in which informal settlement upgrading is being rolled out. Currently it doesn’t account for strong community, civil society, and NGO participation, nor does it address the broader issue of project finance, outsourcing, and party politics.

    The process of upgrading is about learning and letting go, about making space for communities to innovate with the state, about creating a city-wide network/movement that can change the spatial patterns of the city and strengthen citizenship.

    Aditya Kumar is the technical coordinator and deputy director for the Community Organization Resource Centre (CORC), affiliated to Shack/Slum Dwellers International, currently working with informal settlement and backyarder dwellers of South Africa. His previous experience has included post-war reconstruction of Palestinian refugee camps (Lebanon), post-earthquake disaster housing reconstruction (India), affordable and social housing and large urban development projects (Los Angeles and Boston). His work has fostered multi-stakeholder partnerships between local communities, CBOs, government bodies, academic institutions, and International NGOs, with a key focus on strengthening community-driven design, planning, and implementation. The reconstruction of Palestinian refugee camps has also been shortlisted for the Aga Khan Award for Architecture.

    Architect and Lecturer and Researcher, University of Johannesburg

    The National Development Plan’s Outcome 8 agreement is behind the South African government’s current shift towards in situ housing upgrading as a means of redevelopment. This goal of upgrading 400,000 informal settlements has been developed under the mandate of the National Upgrade Support Program.

    Large-scale construction consortiums are working alongside the government, in collaboration with various planning, architectural, and non-governmental entities on the current Reconstruction & Development Program.

    While these initiatives are creating an institutional framework to begin addressing the needs of informal settlement residents in South Africa, there is little focus across the board on training effective practitioners who can play crucial intermediary roles not only in informal settlement upgrading but also in the nation’s spatial redevelopment.

    From my experience in this field, it seems that there are a disproportionately small number of practitioners who have the understanding, experience, or empathy required to engage with the dynamics of informal settlement communities and the complexity of working within the social, economic, and political intricacy that exists between grassroots entities and government structures.

    A major factor for this condition is related to the lack of opportunities for spatial design practitioners (engineers, architects, planners, etc), to be exposed to these complex environments. As a result, many ‘professionals’, as well as many government officials, often display dangerously simplistic views on how to ‘fix’ the problems at hand.

    From my work and experience in academia and the NGO sector, I believe that empathetic spatial design practitioners hold the key position to engage effectively at the ‘community’ level while addressing the larger spatial inequalities of post-apartheid South Africa.

    My aim lies in understanding and sharing contextually appropriate training, practice, and precedents through critical engagement with South Africa’s residents of poor and unsafe living conditions in order to further develop this ‘additional role’ for socio-technical spatial design practice.

    Jhono Bennett is an architect who works at the University of Johannesburg as a part-time lecturer and Independent researcher, while managing the operations of 1:1 — Agency of Engagement, a non-profit entity which he co-founded to provide a design-based collaborative service between grassroots organizations, professionals, academia, and government.

    Masters Program in Housing at the School of Architecture and Planning at the University of the Witwatersrand (South Africa)

    Internationally, there has been unprecedented focus on ‘slums’ in the new millennium. In southern African cities, informal settlements are certainly a concern, although in Anglophone countries the legacy of British colonial planning has to some extent kept these settlements out of middle-class sight. Where informal settlements have intruded into visible locations, as for instance in Lusophone Luanda, recent efforts have been made to remove these to the city periphery. In South Africa, a somewhat reverse government discourse targeted ‘visible’ informal settlements for ‘in situ upgrading’. This approach was adopted by the high profile N2 Gateway Project in Cape Town, which originally targeted all informal settlements that lined the motorway from the airport to the historical city centre for upgrading. In the years that followed, this project morphed into the Luandan approach — the removal of visible informal settlements. In the Cape Town case, removal was to a controlled decanting camp on the far side of the airport. Yet the public was told that the commitment remained to ‘in situ upgrading’. The term was simply given a new meaning, namely for the state to demolish and then build new housing to modern standard for a different clientele.

    With this juxtaposition of informal settlement treatment in Angola and South Africa, I’d like to provoke debate on the core meaning of ‘informal settlement upgrading’ as well as the political uses associated to the meaning. For me, the essence of in situ upgrading is the recognition of two important points. One is that the unevenly developing economies in southern Africa, in the absence of radical change, will not facilitate the replacement of all informal settlements with planned and fully serviced residential developments for the households currently in these settlements. This recognition prevents ‘wishing away’ the reality of urban informality. The other is that informal settlements result out of determination, initiative (often collective), creativity, and complex decisions by poor households. These must be respected and supported where possible.

    Marie Huchzermeyer convenes and teaches in the masters programme in Housing at the School of Architecture and Planning at the University of the Witwatersrand. This base has allowed her to provide support to rights-based struggles from within informal settlement for ‘real’ in situ upgrading. Her recent work includes a 2011 book “Cities With ‘Slums’: From Informal Settlement Eradication to a Right to the City in Africa,” and a comparison with Brazil in a 2004 book, “Unlawful Occupation: Informal Settlements and Urban Policy in South Africa and Brazil.”

  • URBim | for just and inclusive cities

    By Jill Finlayson

    Considering a trip to SXSW in 2014? Vote now for panels that promote greater equity and inclusion. Take a look at our top two picks for several important themes at SXSW: Poverty Alleviation, Education for All, Citizen Engagement, Inclusive Governments, Urban Innovation, and Reinventing Cities.

    Poverty Alleviation

    The World Bank and Innovation: Striking Poverty
    (Jose-Manuel Bassat of the World Bank Institute)

    Mobile Technology Solutions for the Marginalized
    (LinkSF, St. Anthony Foundation, San Francisco Network Ministries, Zendesk, Kimberly McCollister Design)

    Education for All

    Digitally Democratizing Education
    (The Barbarian Group, Africa Community Trust, Newcastle University)

    Reach the Unreachable: Educating More with Less
    (Pencils of Promise, Open Equal Free, Teach For All)

    Citizen Engagement

    Scaling Radical Empowerment Through Technology
    (Change.org)

    The Future of Government-Citizen Interaction
    (Public Stuff)

    Urban Innovation

    The Metropolitan Revolution: Innovation Ecosystems
    (Bruce Katz, The Brookings Institution)

    Cause-Tech Startups: The Opportunity in Good
    (Code for America, Mozilla)

    Reinventing Cities

    The Power of Connecting Cities
    (London Borough of Hackney, Mother London, City of Austin, Bullseye Business Development)

    How Entrepreneurs Reshape Urban Mobility
    (Ford Motor Company, University of Michigan)

    Bonus Picks:

    The Triple Win of Service Learning
    (Team4Tech, Orphans Overseas, VMWare Foundation)

    Design Thinking to Bring Water for All
    (frog, National Institute of Design, India)

    The BRCK – Designing From the Rest of the World
    (Ushahidi and BRCK)

    And if you want overview of what’s happening, consider the Social Good and Civic Engagement Tech Round-Up.